Jump to content

Unknown addition


Recommended Posts

Thanks to Maria Haro Ritchey at Zeiss for the following explanation.
---------------------------------------
PiWeb Reporting is also designed to report out statistic calculations. Because of the MMC the tolerance of the true position changes all the time. For some statistic calculation you need a fix value for the tolerance range.
So we have to create a result that has a fix tolerance corresponding to the result of the flexible tolerance with MMC.

On the attached example:

0.1256 is the tolerance with MMC and 0.05 is the tolerance without MMC.
0.05 / 0.1256 = 0.3980892 is 39.81 %.
True position actual with MMC is 0.0020 and 39.81 % of it is 0.0008

PiWeb_M_on_TP.jpg

Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/20942-unknown-addition/#findComment-119164
Share on other sites

So looking at the report, something is not adding up.

46.88 (OD @ MMC) - 46.766 (Diam) = .114....(214 Bonus). Where is it getting the .194

FCF calls out Con. of 0.1 of the 46.8 OD back to A datum at MMC. So I have applied the MMC to the 46.80 OD.
I have not worked with MMC and Concentricity much so here I am

Am I way off base here?


137_cf06811e7031eb9436659bdffc976a8c.jpg
Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/20942-unknown-addition/#findComment-119172
Share on other sites

Tom, in response to your 1st answer – I understand how the (M) characteristic is calculated but I’m not understanding its’ purpose. Also, the original true position result isn’t correct. If I calculate diametrical true position using the listed X and Z numbers the result is 0.00189737. Not .0020. Even if I round up the result would be .0019. And regardless of the amount of tolerance, the features’ true position will always be this amount. Its’ just a matter of being in or out of tolerance. So I’m not understanding where the .002 comes from, and what the .0008 represents. IE: Why do I need to know what that number is?
Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/20942-unknown-addition/#findComment-119188
Share on other sites

Jack, I'm guessing there must be some rounding going on out beyond the 4 places you're showing. In other words the .0003 and the .0009 could actually be larger, thus calculating the TP to the .002 number. That's the only thing I can think is going on. You could try increasing the number of decimal places to 5 or 6 to see if that is true.

As far as the (M), it has to do with people who are running SPC. Since SPC requires you to use the tolerance in the calculation and MMC does not produce a fixed tolerance and changes with every part, the calculation for the (M) allows people to process the (M) values for their SPC. At least, this is what I understood from Maria.
Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/20942-unknown-addition/#findComment-119190
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...