Jump to content

gage r&r


---

Recommended Posts

Please sign in to view this username.

 If he is trying to prove the CMM is repeatable, no to the casting. There's too much variability with raw parts. Use a more refined, known artifact like your training block. If he is looking at production measurement system capability, then let him use the castings. I'd do both, so you can show the variability that exists between them.

Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/27884-gage-rr/#findComment-158302
Share on other sites

I do a five run R&R on every single characteristic in every program I write, including cast surfaces. This includes removing the part from the fixturing and placing it back in the fixturing so I know that process repeats too. If something doesn't fall within the 10% measurement error rule, I change the scanning, filtering, or whatever else it takes to get it to repeat (and be accurate). If it doesn't repeat, how do I know which measurement is the right one (if any)? There are so many programmers out there that don't want to do R&Rs and I don't know why. It only makes you a better programmer, and people trust the numbers you give them. The big drawback of course is the amount of time it takes to prove out a program. The last program I had one of my operators prove was a big one and took about a day and a half to do the R&R. They don't like the time factor, but they, the machinists, and the engineers are much more confident in the numbers they're seeing and are willing to wait. I do make exceptions though for really big programs (ones that take 2 or 3 hours for each run) or the really big parts that take a crane to lift. I'll usually only have them do a 3 run R&R.

  • Like! 4
Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/27884-gage-rr/#findComment-158352
Share on other sites

I do R&Rs on selective features only.

I use close tolerance features and locations.

If you base your loose tolerance features on the same parameters as your close tolerance features you should have no issues testing only close tolerance features.

We have parts that run upwards of 4 hours per program, in some cases a single part will collect over 2,400 dims, and total run time is around 7 hours.

I can do a Gage R&R in about 40 minutes for one program.

This will save you a lot of time, and management loves to save time.

Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/27884-gage-rr/#findComment-158458
Share on other sites

It's been 20 some years, but I believe Gauge R&R on new programs should be emphasized in basic and then even more in advance training.

Not only is Zeiss’s reputation hindered when a bad part inspects good or a good part inspects bad and then checks different the 2nd time it’s checked, the CMM and its programmers reputations precedes it.

Literally thousands of hours and money are lost over time.

I spent a lot of time at IMTS this year talking with several measuring machine company sales representatives and guess what? Programming is easy and damn near bullet proof, anybody can do it, if it doesn't do it itself.:classic_cool:

  • Like! 1
Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/27884-gage-rr/#findComment-158468
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...