Jump to content

Make this make sense


Recommended Posts

Please sign in to view this quote.

When there is a position callout that is not fully constrained, a sub alignment should not be used in the position characteristic's evaluation. If you look below the sub alignment's name you see (Base Alignment) which means any open slot gets automatically filled in by what was used in the base alignment, making it fully constrained. That's why you see the same result. Attached a Zeiss document explaining this.

If the print callout is only to -AB- then you must only enter datums -A- and -B- in the position characteristic. No need for the 3DLine.

Also, when you create your base alignment, the features are evaluated as LSQ. Which is what you want. It's the most stable, repeatable evaluation. When you enter your features in the position characteristic, they should be evaluated as Outer Tangential for Planes and Max Inscribe for ID's and Min Circumscribe for OD's. Hence why you would see the difference.

Align_vs_Datum_Ref_Frame.pdf

  • Like! 3
Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/24289-make-this-make-sense/#findComment-137491
Share on other sites

If you do not define enough datums to fully constrain calypso will give nonsense numbers.  Datums consume all possible constraints as they are applied.  (If datum A was a sphere, datum B would constrain nothing!) 

In its defense, the new GDT engine in 2024 features will show you an exclamation point when left unrestrained and it is GREAT

Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/24289-make-this-make-sense/#findComment-137561
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...