Jump to content

Recommended Posts

---

I have a print where non-toleranced features fall under Note 7.

Note 7 is a profile of Unequal Distribution .040/.010

Then there is Note 17, which allows for a surface condition.

See attached image.

How do I implement Note 17 in the Profile requirement?

Edit: 

I am unable to find a single instance where Flag Note 17 is applied to a feature.

All Notes are "Unless Otherwise Specified".

Now I wonder if Note 17 is a general note and not applicable on this particular blueprint.

Screenshot 2026-06-24 065909.jpg

Edited
  • Like! 1
Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/26873-a-gdt-question-for-profile/
Share on other sites

---

Never had something like this before. 

 

I would measure the depth of surface texture (value below 0,015) and hope that it is quite uniform and put it on the tolerance (additive).

Now do you put it on the tolerance out or in the material or 50/50?

This is pretty much impossible by the info given alone. One could decide depending on how the texture is achieved. Is something added to achieve the texture or is something removed to achieve the texture?

 

Thinking about the wording ... I would read "in addition" as additive material wise (non native speaker).

---
Posted (edited)

Snippet from the print, initially I read this as two separate instructions.

Now I am leaning on the Note 9 is a construct of how Flag Note 17 is applied where applicable while Note 9 may encompass any feature on the part generated under the instruction.

Note 9 is a general note falling under the initial heading above the notes "Unless Otherwise Specified".

Note 17 is a flag note.

 

Screenshot 2026-06-24 145210.jpg

Edited
---

The way I was reading balloon 2101 is that the surface has the UOS and an "additional" requirement. 

The first requirement (Note 7) would be: PROFILE| .040 U .030|A|B|C

The second requirement (Note 17) would depend on what "MEASURED SURFACE" means.

If measured surface = nominal surface, then size and form would be controlled by: PROFILE| .015 U .015| to no datums.

if measured surface = actual surface, then only form would be controlled by: DYNAMIC PROFILE| .015| to no datums.

The surface would need to be  inside both profile tolerance zones.

  • Like! 1
---

I was kind of thinking along the lines of Edgar, 

Where the profile callout is giving you more of a location reference and the note is giving you a form reference. 

Whereas if you were to think of it as a flat surface, the location of the surface needs to align within the main profile callout, but then no part of that surface can vary by more than the note almost like a .015 flatness

×
×
  • Create New...