Jump to content

CAA probe calibration magic


Recommended Posts

I recently had a problem that took me way too long to figure out.  I had a part that measured great except for the few features that were measured with the angled probe.  I beat my head against it and eventually discovered that the issue was the calibration with the regular straight 3mm probe on a 75 mm stem.  It was off by almost 0.03".  I think that what had happened was that somebody had not revalued the reference sphere before calibration.  The interesting thing is that the numbers on the calibration were great.  It looked like a good calibration. Good sigma etc.

With roughly 100 features measured using over 10 probe orientations of basically every approach angle with that probe it agreed with itself.  Holes on one side of the part were directly in line with holes on the other side of the part.  I would expect that to not be the case.  The Y direction was off by almost 0.03" (not to mention the issues in X though Z was good). So when I am probing from the +X side vs probing from the -X side with a generic probe, if the reference sphere location was wrong by 0.03" I would expect the holes on the two sides to be off by 0.06" relative to eachother.  

I think the CAA just does a ton of magic to bring those into alignment so that anything with that probe is basically good to other things with that same probe.  But if you use another probe with a regular calibration ... especially a good calibration ... the two probes will disagree by the offset in the reference sphere location, or about 0.03" in this case.

Does that sound right?  Does anybody else have more insight or experience with this?  I cannot afford the cmm time to truly test the theory.

Link to comment
https://qualityforum.zeiss.com/topic/27828-caa-probe-calibration-magic/
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

I ran into this recently when tracking down an error and spent along time trying to wrap my head around it. I'll leave it to more experienced RDS users (former Vast exclusive guy) to confirm but yes. When I ran my verification program from standard calibration styli against RDS-CAA Styli I saw a major move but in general the CAA calibrations were just not as good because of how it's making a mathematical model essentially to try and cover all of the positions. I'm looking at transferring what I can to a list calibration as everything here previously was set up to CAA except for 1 stylus. Still figuring that out

If you're seeing .03" difference, even using CAA, you have another problem. The difference between using CAA compared to individual probe angles not using CAA is nowhere near that amount of difference. This sounds like a calibration issue. Do you use more than 1 reference sphere? What is your calibration procedure? 

×
×
  • Create New...